As the subtitle of this new picture book says, "There Are Two Sides to Every Story". Finding the welcoming, open-hearted, willing-to-share side of life comes more naturally to kids, but our future depends on people of EVERY age shifting attitudes and speaking up. In life, as in quality picture books, EVERY age can find inspiration and truth, if they are open to making connections with their own lives.
Kane Miller Books 2019 |
I wrote about REVERSO POEMS in an earlier post, HERE. These, too, reflect alternate points of view: conflicting characters, creator/craft, etc.
In this book, though, the alternating approaches reflect much deeper differences.Central values.
The frames through which we view the world. Without reading in both directions, either message is diminished. The concluding/launching line directs readers:
"No room on this rock? Can it be true? Read back to front for another point of view."
The gull reminders are an added nudge to readers about when-where-how to proceed:
The other illustrations throughout take on entirely different emotional resonance as the point of view reverses. The degree and awareness of threat throughout the story also diminish or magnify depending on which point of view is promoted.
Without giving too much away, this distinctly expressive seal colony and family-in-need either question their commonalities or embrace them. One story, without the other, feels valid. it is only when both are viewed in sequence, and even with repeated explorations, that readers (of any age) can identify the realities that formed various perspectives.
Either way, the desperate seal pair are escaping undeniable dangers. Either way, the sanctuary rock has clearly been claimed as home by others, possibly long before the approach of strangers is evident. The difference in result is found not in circumstances but in attitude.
Discussions this book will generate are worth having, at any age.
Most especially, this book could launch a successful school year, allowing connections to ways sharing supplies and turn-taking and game participation and empathy and acceptance can reshape the experiences of a year spent growing and learning together.
The book also offers an opening to science discussions of predator-prey, climate change, and how supply-demand in nature creates tensions that challenge investigators to find alternatives to either-or solutions.
It's a book that could launch a thousand discussions of the current refugee crisis in older classrooms, too, and among adults. I can see a role for this book in religious services of various denominations, echoing the questions of needs versus resources but reminding participants of that important frame-shifting process. Consideration of what ethical and spiritual commitments require is bound to arise.
Harking back to the assumption that picture books are meant for "little kids", ROOM ON OUR ROCK will be a delight for read-aloud times with even the youngest groups in preschools and library story times. Its wide double-page spreads mirror the expanse of the ocean, while its limited text and simple color palette allow focus on the characters and crisis. The reverse in directions of reading will be especially appealing to little eyes and hands who are still developing concepts of left-to-right and other concepts-of-print awareness.
In other words, this is a book that fulfills its primary purpose: to entertain and absorb, to invite repeated readings and discussion.
And, like the very best picture books, it is COMPLETE, COMPACT, and COMPELLING, offering something for every age and audience.
Thank you to Kane Miller Books for reaching out to offer a copy of this book for review, with no promise in return. I will be donating it to our local library.
Sounds like a very interesting book. TY, Sandy for sharing this with us. I have a CP wo could use this as a mentor text.
ReplyDeleteKathy, It is a delight, really, and the simple-but-expressive faces of the seals generate a strong sense of mood. The ability for it to change meaning entirely by reversing the order of the phrases would be a wonderful mentor-text challenge for young writers and also a terrific exercise on the power of line breaks in otherwise straightforward sentences. Hope you enjoy it, and thanks for stopping by to read and comment.
DeleteSounds fascinating. I cant wait to take a look.
ReplyDeleteHope you enjoy it. This is such a great example of a book tat can be shared and explored and enjoyed in a relatively short time, but become a touchpoint for countless issues and obstacles as time unfolds in a classroom. I hope you enjoy it!
Delete